There is no one right answer
Renting is not throwing money away, and buying is not automatically a good investment. Both are ways to pay for a place to live. The better choice depends on your savings, your income, how long you plan to stay, and what you want from a home. My job is to help you see the numbers clearly, not to talk you into a purchase.
When renting can make sense
Renting is often the better fit if you might move for work or family in the next few years, or if a down payment would empty your savings and leave nothing for repairs or a job change. It also makes sense while you are still deciding between Surrey, Langley, Abbotsford, or somewhere else, or between a condo, a townhouse, and a house. If your credit or income history is new, a little more time can make the mortgage process easier.
Renting gives you flexibility, and the landlord usually handles big repairs. That has real value, even if it does not show up as equity.
When buying can make sense
Buying tends to fit better when you plan to stay put for several years, you have a down payment plus money for closing costs and an emergency fund, and the full monthly cost of owning fits your budget comfortably, not just on paper. Some people also want the control that comes with owning: renovating, having pets, adding a suite where the zoning allows it, or simply not having to move because a landlord decides to sell.
What really counts as a cost
When people compare rent with a mortgage payment, they often compare the wrong things. Part of every mortgage payment pays down the principal. That part is not gone. It becomes equity in your home. The costs of owning that you do not get back are:
- Mortgage interest
- Property tax
- Strata fees or maintenance, plus repairs on a detached home
- Home insurance
- Property transfer tax and legal or notary fees at closing
- Mortgage default insurance, if your down payment is under 20%
On the renting side, the cost is rent, which usually goes up over time, minus whatever your savings can earn while they stay invested instead of going into a down payment. A fair comparison also has to account for the monthly difference. The chart below assumes that whoever has the lower monthly cost invests the difference at the same return: the renter when owning costs more, the owner when renting costs more. You can turn that off if you would rather compare without it.
A home's value can rise, stay flat, or fall, and nobody can promise which. That is why the chart below lets you set that assumption yourself, including zero or a negative number.
Down payment and mortgage insurance basics
In Canada, the minimum down payment is 5% of the first $500,000 of the purchase price and 10% of the portion above $500,000, for homes under $1.5 million. At $1.5 million or more, the minimum is 20%. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada explains this on its down payment page.
If you put down less than 20%, the mortgage needs default insurance, from CMHC or a private insurer. The premium is a percentage of the loan. It is higher when your down payment is smaller, and it is usually added to the mortgage, so you pay interest on it too. CMHC explains how it works on its mortgage loan insurance page. Your lender or mortgage broker confirms what applies to you. If you have not talked to one yet, my guide to getting pre-approved in B.C. is a good place to start.
The first-time buyer property transfer tax exemption
Property transfer tax is a British Columbia closing cost, paid when the home is registered in your name. If you qualify as a first-time home buyer, the tax can be fully exempt on a home with a fair market value of $500,000 or less. Above that, the exemption is a reduction of up to $8,000, and it phases out between $835,000 and $860,000. Other conditions apply, including living in the home as your principal residence. The Province explains the details on its first-time home buyers' program page, and my first-time home buyer guide walks through an example.
A lawyer or notary confirms the property transfer tax.
How long you plan to stay matters
Buying has big costs at the start: transfer tax, legal fees, possibly mortgage insurance, and the move itself. In the early years, most of each mortgage payment is interest. The longer you stay, the more those upfront costs are spread out, and the more of each payment goes to principal. That is why the same home can look expensive over two years and much more reasonable over ten.
Selling later also has costs, and the chart does not include them. If there is a real chance you will move within a few years, give renting a close look. Use the years slider below to see where the two lines cross with your own numbers.